Federal and state prison grievance processes are governed by entirely different rules. If your loved one is in a state facility, the federal Administrative Remedy Process does not apply. Here is how to tell the difference and what it means.
Before doing anything else, you need to know whether your loved one is in a federal prison or a state prison. This is not always obvious, and getting it wrong means following the wrong process entirely.
Federal prisons are operated by the Bureau of Prisons (BOP), a federal agency under the U.S. Department of Justice. They house people convicted of federal crimes — drug trafficking, bank robbery, immigration offenses, white-collar crimes, and others. Federal prison names often include words like "Federal Correctional Institution" (FCI), "United States Penitentiary" (USP), "Federal Prison Camp" (FPC), or "Federal Detention Center" (FDC).
State prisons are operated by individual state departments of corrections. They house people convicted of state crimes — most violent crimes, property crimes, and drug offenses prosecuted under state law. State prison names vary widely by state.
The easiest way to confirm is to look at the inmate's conviction. If they were convicted in a U.S. District Court (a federal court), they are in the federal system. If they were convicted in a state court (Superior Court, Circuit Court, District Court at the state level), they are in the state system.
You can also look up the facility directly on the BOP's inmate locator at bop.gov/inmateloc/.
Federal inmates must follow the four-step Administrative Remedy Process governed by 28 CFR Part 542:
This process is uniform across all federal facilities. The same forms, the same deadlines, and the same rules apply whether the inmate is in a minimum-security camp in Florida or a maximum-security penitentiary in Colorado.
Each state has its own grievance process, and they vary significantly. Some states have a two-step process; others have three or four steps. Deadlines range from 5 days to 30 days. Forms differ. The offices that receive appeals differ.
| Feature | Federal (BOP) | State (varies) |
|---|---|---|
| Governing regulation | 28 CFR Part 542 | State-specific |
| Number of steps | 4 (BP-8 through BP-11) | 2–5 depending on state |
| Initial deadline | 20 days from incident | 5–30 days depending on state |
| Uniform across facilities | Yes | No — varies by facility |
| Required before federal lawsuit | Yes (PLRA) | Yes (PLRA) |
Yes. The Prison Litigation Reform Act's exhaustion requirement applies to both federal and state prisoners. A state prisoner who wants to file a federal civil rights lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 must first exhaust their state prison's grievance process — whatever that process is.
This means that even though the specific steps differ, the consequence of getting it wrong is the same: a federal court will dismiss the lawsuit for failure to exhaust.
Because state processes vary so much, it is important to get information specific to the state where your loved one is incarcerated. Resources include:
Remedy Navigators currently specializes in the federal BOP Administrative Remedy Process. For state prisoners, we recommend contacting a state-specific prisoner rights organization for guidance on the applicable process.
Sources: 28 CFR Part 542 (Federal Administrative Remedy Program); 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(a) (PLRA exhaustion); BOP Inmate Locator at bop.gov/inmateloc/.
Know someone who needs this?
Every time you share this article, another family learns about their rights before it's too late.